My Honest Avocado Mattress Review After One Year: Is It Worth It?
I've had my Avocado mattress for a year now, which I think is long enough to move past the honeymoon phase of a new mattress and figure out whether you actually like sleeping on it.
4
I’ve had my Avocado mattress for a year now, which I think is long enough to move past the honeymoon phase of a new mattress and figure out whether you actually like sleeping on it.
I originally bought an Avocado mattress for our guest room, but I actually sleep on it myself fairly regularly given how wildly different mine and my partner’s sleep schedules can sometimes be, which has given me plenty of opportunities to test the mattress.
TL;DR: After a year, I can confidently say there are things I really love about it, and one thing I would do differently if I bought one today would be to go with the plush version, or a topper on the standard version.
Why I Chose Avocado in the First Place

I’ve been making an effort to prioritize nontoxic products in our home (including our cookware and recently, tupperware), especially things we spend a significant amount of time using. And considering we spend roughly a third of our lives sleeping, mattresses seem like a pretty logical place to start.
Traditional mattresses can contain polyurethane foam, synthetic adhesives, and chemical flame retardants, depending on how they’re made. That doesn’t automatically make every conventional mattress unsafe, but I do prefer to avoid certain materials when there are good alternatives.
That’s what initially drew me to Avocado – they focus on natural and organic materials, including latex, wool, and cotton, and offer mattresses with third-party certifications that help substantiate their material and emissions claims.
I also liked that they’re made locally in the US, and that sustainability is a major part of the company’s identity.
My Experience with the Avocado Wool Mattress
One of the main reasons I chose the Avocado Wool Mattress was that I wanted a latex-free option.
A lot of mattresses marketed as natural or organic use natural latex, which can be a great material. But if I’m already going out of my way to find a mattress made with natural materials, I wanted to see what the alternatives were. Avocado’s wool mattress uses wool as a primary comfort material rather than latex.
Wool is naturally breathable, helps regulate temperature, and can provide cushioning without relying on synthetic polyurethane foam. I also appreciate that wool has natural flame-resistant properties, allowing mattresses to meet applicable flammability standards without certain added chemical flame retardants.
However I mostly chose it since the combo of price and firmness advertised fit what I wanted. However once the mattress arrived I greatly disagreed with the company’s assessment of how firm it was, and so did most of the reviewers. I’ve seen since that they’ve updated the firmness to reflect closer to what I feel it is – about a 7/8 out of 10.
Why I Kept It
The mattress has a very supportive, fairly rigid feel, with less cushioning than I personally would have preferred, but this is the bed I sometimes sleep in when my son wants to share, and for him, a firm mattress is much better.
Firm mattresses can be great for back sleepers (both of us are), and those with back pain issues. I don’t mind this mattress, but if I ever decide we need something softer, I’ll probably get one of their toppers.
Now, firmness is subjective. Your body weight, sleeping position, and personal preferences all affect how a mattress feels.
But I think it’s worth emphasizing that if you’re someone who loves a soft, cozy mattress that you can really sink into, this probably isn’t the one for you. I’d go for their plush version if that’s what you’re hoping for.
Especially if you’re a side sleeper who needs more pressure relief around your shoulders and hips.
If you’re in California, where Avocado has showrooms, I would strongly recommend visiting one and trying the mattresses in person before buying.
I can sleep on it comfortably enough, and I have chosen to keep it. But if I were buying another mattress and softness were a top priority, I’d be looking at Avocado’s other options.
Avocado Makes Crib Mattresses too!
Avocado also makes organic crib mattresses, which are worth considering if you’re trying to create a nontoxic nursery. Babies spend an incredible amount of time sleeping (even if it doesn’t always feel that way at 3 a.m.), so it makes sense to be particularly thoughtful about what they’re sleeping on. Avocado offers several options, including Eco, Organic, and Luxury crib mattresses, made with materials like organic cotton, wool, and natural latex, depending on the model.
Avocado’s crib mattresses have GOTS organic certification, and the company publishes independent testing for substances like PFAS. They’re also designed to provide the firm, flat sleep surface babies need for safe sleep. Unlike my complaint about their adult wool mattress being too firm, this is one situation where firmness is exactly what you want! Some models are also dual-sided, with different surfaces for infants and toddlers.
Is the Avocado Wool Mattress Worth the Money?

I think it can be, if your priorities are natural materials, avoiding latex, third-party certifications, and a firm, supportive sleeping surface, I think the Avocado Wool Mattress is a compelling option.
I appreciate the construction, the material choices, and the company’s efforts toward sustainability, but with this brand, I recommend going one level softer than you think you’ll want, as my experience and others’ I’ve read all seem to echo the same sentiment – they’re harder than we thought they’d be. A mattress can have every certification in the world, but if you don’t enjoy sleeping on it, that’s a pretty significant problem.
Would I Buy an Avocado Mattress Again?
Yes, but I would probably choose a different model. I’ve had my Avocado Wool Mattress for a year, I still use it regularly, and I’ve decided to keep it, even though I could have returned it based on their return policy.
If I were shopping for our primary bedroom and wanted something softer, I’d look at Avocado’s other mattresses and compare their comfort options before deciding.
*Some links in this post are affiliate links that support us at no extra cost to you when you purchase through them. We only recommend products we love and use ourselves. Your trust always comes first!

