My Honest Caraway Review After 4 Years: Is It Worth the Money?

I've been using Caraway cookware for four years now, which I feel like officially qualifies me to give a review beyond “look how pretty these pans are!”

Editor's Rating:
4

I’ve been using Caraway cookware for four years now, which I feel like officially qualifies me to give a review beyond “look how pretty these pans are!”

And they are pretty. Like, make-you-want-to-keep-your-kitchen-clean pretty. But after four years of cooking with them almost daily, I have some thoughts on whether or not they’re worth buying. I’ve also since replaced my original set with an entirely new one, so clearly the cons haven’t scared me off.

But is Caraway actually worth the money? For me, yes, and they’re almost always on some kind of sale. Here’s everything to know before you buy them:

Why I Bought Caraway in the First Place

I try to prioritize nontoxic products in our home, especially when it comes to things we’re using every single day (like strollers, car seats, play couches, and mattresses). Cookware was one of the first places I wanted to make a change.

The problem? I am simply not a stainless steel cookware girl.

I know, you’re supposed to learn how to heat the pan to exactly the right temperature, add the oil at precisely the right moment, wait for the food to release itself, and somehow not end up scraping half your dinner off the bottom. I’m sure it’s a skill. It’s just not one I’m particularly interested in mastering while trying to get dinner on the table.

That’s what initially drew me to Caraway. Their ceramic-coated cookware is made without PFAS, including PTFE (the coating commonly associated with traditional Teflon pans), and it has that easy-release surface I love.

They also make stainless steel cookware now, if you’re a better cook than I am and actually know how to use it.

Pro #1: They’re Actually Third-Party Tested for PFAS

One thing I appreciate about Caraway is that they’re not just throwing around the word “nontoxic” and expecting us to take their word for it. Caraway publishes independent third-party testing results for its cookware, including testing for PFAS, heavy metals, and other substances.

Their ceramic cookware has been tested by Light Labs, with PTFE and PFOA reported as not detected. Caraway also says its ceramic coating is made without intentionally added PFAS, lead, or cadmium.

Of course, no testing can prove that absolutely every potentially harmful substance is absent, and “nontoxic” isn’t a regulated blanket guarantee of safety.

But I do appreciate that there’s actual testing available to look at rather than just marketing language. For me, avoiding PFAS-based nonstick coatings is one of the main reasons I switched in the first place.

Pro #2: They’re Really Beautiful

I realize aesthetics shouldn’t be the deciding factor when buying cookware, but if I’m going to spend this much money on pots and pans, I would prefer that they not look like they survived a college apartment.

Caraway looks beautiful sitting on the stove. The colors are chic, the design is minimalist, and the whole collection makes my kitchen feel a little more put together, even when the rest of the house is covered in toys.

I love that the cookware looks like something you’d actually want to display instead of immediately shoving into a cabinet. And with so many color options, it’s easy to find something that works with your kitchen.

Although I do have one very specific warning about which color to choose, which I’ll get to below.

Pro #4: The Whole Collection Looks Great Together

I’ve actually gone beyond the cookware and upgraded all of our food storage containers to Caraway as well. Yes, I’ve reached the stage of adulthood where matching food storage containers bring me genuine happiness.

Their glass food storage containers are particularly appealing because I prefer storing food in glass rather than plastic whenever possible. And unlike the mismatched collection of containers and mysteriously missing lids we had before, everything looks organized. It’s a little ridiculous how satisfying that is.

I also love that Caraway has expanded into bakeware, kitchen tools, and other products, so you can keep a consistent look throughout your kitchen.

Do you need matching cookware and food storage? Absolutely not. Do I enjoy having it? Very much.

Plus, it’s cheaper when you buy it all together as a bundle.

Con #1: The Nonstick Coating Lasted About Three Years for Me

Here’s the part I think is really important to know before investing in Caraway: in my experience, the ceramic nonstick coating lasts around three years.

After about 3 years I started noticing little chips in the coating of the frying pans and realized I wasn’t alone after looking at forums and seeing similar experiences. That’s not just a Caraway problem, it’s a coating problem, particularly compared with uncoated stainless steel or cast iron, which can last for decades.

Caraway recommends cooking over low to medium heat, avoiding metal utensils, and hand-washing to help preserve the coating. I can follow most of those, except the heat. That’s like asking me to drive a Ferrari no more than 25mph – it’s an unreasonable expectation.

However pans will degrade at different rates depending on how much you use them. Our baking sheets and large pot are still going strong 4 years on, and adding up the cost and dividing between 3 years, I decided the investment was worth it to me, even if they need replacing. I’ve also found that listing things for free on Facebook marketplace means they’ll get picked up within minutes. While a chipped pan isn’t ideal, it might be replacing something much worse for the person picking up your old pans.

Con #2: Don’t Buy the Cream Color Unless You Love Cleaning

My original Caraway set was cream, which looked absolutely beautiful when it arrived. Unfortunately, cooking stains show up on the light-colored exterior, and over time, they became increasingly noticeable.

Caraway includes a cleaning sponge to help remove stubborn marks, and I’m sure there are people out there who have the patience to meticulously clean their cookware back to its original pristine condition, but I am not one of those people.

So when I bought my second set, I went with sage green instead. It’s still beautiful, but I’m much happier with a color that doesn’t showcase every little cooking stain quite so enthusiastically.

Unless you’re extremely diligent about keeping your cookware spotless, choose a darker color.

Would I Buy Caraway Again?

Well, I already did! I think that probably says more than anything else in this review.

Despite the fact that the nonstick coating doesn’t last forever, I still really like cooking with Caraway. I love the design, I appreciate the third-party testing, and I like how easy it is to cook with and clean.

I’ve even expanded into their food storage collection, which I also love. Would I prefer that a premium-priced pan lasted 10 or 20 years? Of course. But the reality is that I prioritize having a nonstick surface, and I’m willing to accept that ceramic nonstick cookware has a limited lifespan.

My verdict after four years? I like it enough to buy it twice. Just don’t get the cream color.

*Some links in this post are affiliate links that support us at no extra cost to you when you purchase through them. We only recommend products we love and use ourselves. Your trust always comes first!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.