REBEL vs. Goodbuy Gear – I Tried Both to See Which is Better

If you’re a parent diving deep into the world of affordable baby gear – a realm of strollers, cribs, and all things tiny human – you might have stumbled upon two popular platforms: REBEL (formerly Rebelstork) and GoodBuy Gear. Both offer great deals on open box items, and you’re probably wondering which one is the better choice.

I’ve bought several times from both platforms, and while they may seem similar on the surface, they differ when it comes to policies, inventory, and overall customer experience.

Here’s everything to know in the showdown of REBEL (formerly Rebelstork) vs. GoodBuy Gear:

Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links that support us at no extra cost to you. This sponsored post is brought to you by REBEL, and details my extensive firsthand experiences with both platforms.

What are REBEL and GoodBuy Gear?

REBEL and GoodBuy Gear are both online marketplaces that help parents save money on baby gear. However, there’s a key difference: REBEL is North America’s largest retailer for open-box and overstock products at up to 50% OFF. This means all the items on their site, from baby gear to home essentials, are simply opened but never used. 

GoodBuy Gear, founded in 2016 in the U.S., focuses on making parenting more affordable and sustainable by reselling used and open box baby gear. Open box means returns, floor models, or overstock items that are still like-new but deeply discounted—ideal for parents looking for quality gear from the brands they love without the full retail price.

Founded in 2020 in Canada by Emily Hosie, REBEL (formerly Rebelstork) offers a cheaper and greener alternative to retail by keeping high-quality baby gear in circulation and out of landfills, where the majority of baby gear returns ends up. For example, Ex. if you return a stroller because it doesn’t fit into your entryway, that usually doesn’t make it back to the store shelf, it goes straight to the landfill even when it has never been used! REBEL is the only B Corp in the industry that helps keep +25 Million pounds of returned products out of landfills annually. 

With partnerships spanning over 2,500 retailers and brands, they offer an amazing selection of products like Keenz, 7am Enfant, Babyzen, GB, and more.

Home Essentials and Baby Gear

REBEL has offered open box baby gear for years, and they’re now expanding beyond baby gear, selling home essentials too, making it even easier for parents to find deals on everything they need.

REBEL now offers kitchenware, tabletop items, decor, furniture, bedding, and bath with popular brands like Beautiful, KitchenAid, Cuisinart, and Nespresso.

REBEL vs. GoodBuy Gear: Inventory and Deals

I’ve found fantastic deals on both platforms, from strollers to high chairs and even diapers. But what sets REBEL apart is their extensive selection of open box items—ensuring parents get high-quality products that are practically new at up to 50% off. While I have no problem buying secondhand, open box is usually preferable as there are always some unknowns with secondhand gear, and holds a nice resale value when I’m done using the item. 

Some bestsellers include the EVENFLO Revolve360 Extend All-in-One Rotational Car Seat, GRACO Modes Pramette Travel System, KEENZ XC+ 2.0 Luxury Comfort 4 Passenger Stroller Wagon, LALO The Chair, and more.

I have personally scored strollers, a baby snowsuit, and Keenz wagon at deep discounts on REBEL, which has also expanded to home essentials like kitchenware, tabletop items, decor, furniture, bedding, and bath at up to 50% off retail prices. 

I’ve also purchased the WayB Pico, Bentley Trike, and even diapers from GoodBuy Gear.

REBEL vs. GoodBuy Gear: Quality Control & Return Policies

For peace of mind, I’d recommend always checking your REBEL order as soon as it arrives. It’s important to find and report any problems within their 7-day return window. Recent items I received were as good as new. 

GoodBuy Gear also offers 14 days in their return window, with an optional added 7-day return insurance for extra flexibility.

For both cases, it’s important to know that original warranties often won’t apply, so check your items thoroughly. 

Final Thoughts:

It’s worth browsing both of them since their inventory can vary from week to week and they both offer great discounts on baby gear.

The biggest difference is REBEL only offers open box, and also has housewares.

GoodBuy Gear has open box and also offers secondhand options, and there are some amazing deals on there as well, particularly for certified pre-owned car seats.